Valdosta Daily Times

Local News

September 22, 2009

Education is not one size fits all

State board listens to concerns

STATENVILLE — A discussion on the current state of Georgia’s public education system was helmed by a member of the State Board of Education Tuesday night in Statenville.

Linda Zechmann, First Congressional District representative, held her annual public hearing on the state of Georgia’s education.

The Echols County School System hosted the event which brought in teachers, educators and board members from Cook, Lanier, Tift, Echols, Lowndes and Valdosta City School Systems. Buck Hilliard, executive director of the State Board of Education, was also in attendance.

Though Zechmann represents more than 20 counties in the First Congressional District, the attendance was less than the number of counties she represents.

Zechmann said as a member of the board she brings “uncommon, common sense.”

“If it doesn’t make sense to me, an average person, it's not going to make sense to you,” Zechmann said.

The purpose of the public hearings is for Zechmann to hear the concerns of the district and answer any questions they may have, she said.

Before opening up the meeting to the audience, Zechmann urged them to use the www.gadoe.org Web site to find information on Adequate Yearly Progress, Georgia Performance Standards, the board’s budget, what is new with the board and legislation concerning education.

The Web site has detailed information on GPS, and Zechmann said teachers can even direct parents to the Web site so they can better understand the curriculum and what their children are being taught.

Two teachers from Valdosta Middle School opened the public participation portion of the hearing. Kristy James and Karen Black said they were not there to represent their school but to voice the thoughts of a wide variety of teachers from different school systems about federal and state policies that affect the classroom.

Since the meeting was announced, Black said they had been discussing with their peers the ideas they would like to convey to the board. Both stated that these are not issues affecting just VCS but all schools in the state of Georgia.

The curriculum, a combination of federal and state policy has put higher pressure on both students and teachers to perform, Black said.

The amount and level of work required to be done in a classroom in a given day or class period has made a more personal level of understanding between teacher and student difficult, she said. Test anxiety for students is higher than ever before, Black said. James said the curriculum is requiring students with a 68 IQ pass a test that students with a 100 IQ find difficult.

“It's like asking a student to get out of a wheelchair and walk,” James said. The GPS no longer allows teachers to formally teach basic facts and computation, she said.

While it is great for students with disabilities and learning impairments to participate in a regular classroom, it is almost impossible to believe they will perform at the same standards, James said.

Providing special certificates or diplomas to those that cannot perform at college prep level would keep a lot of students from falling through the cracks, she said.

Those students that make great gains in a year, but still fail a CRCT test, should still have that progress count for something, James said.

Afterwards, Zechmann asked them to e-mail her a copy of their prepared statement and that she would get them in touch with someone at the State Department of Education.

“I don’t feel personally qualified to address those issues,” Zechmann said.

Zechmann said the difficulty with making a state policy concerning education is that “one size does not fit all.”

Dr. Steve Smith, Lowndes County Superintendent, said they were expressing the frustrations that everyone feels concerning No Child Left Behind.

Seventy-percent of the NCLB is great, 25 percent of it is unreasonable, he said.

All children will not be able to read on grade level by 2010, Smith said.

“Unless you eradicate intellectual disabilities,” he said. "Something that would be impossible." The key is developing practical, realistic goals, he said.

Dr. Larry Allen, Echols County Superintendent, stressed the importance of Coastal Plains RESA.

The network between schools that the organization provides has helped the small school system tremendously over the years, he said.

When the school was in need of desks, they were donated by LCS, when the school needed training on block scheduling they went to VCS, lockers for the gymnasium were acquired from Cook County, he said.

Zechmann said the issue of whether to continue RESA or combine it with another entity is something that comes up almost annually in the General Assembly.

She said she was squarely in Allen’s court on the benefits of RESA.

Text Only
Local News
  • mqdefault.jpg Weekend preview with Brittany McClure

    Find out what's going on this weekend with Brittany McClure.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • 120524 pnut lady4.jpg Popular vendor taken out of the ballparks

    With a wagon-load of fresh cakes, hot boiled peanuts and ice-cold bottled water she has witnessed generations of children, or as she refers to them, her angels, grow into adults with children of their own.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • ELECTION-graphic.jpg Three candidates file for election

    Qualifications for Lowndes County general primaries continue with the addition of a couple new candidates interested in running for elected office.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • money.jpg City, county tax discussions stalled

    Local Option Sales Tax “negotiations” between city and county officials have descended from open meetings to a stalemate, with no clear agreement on how the estimated $210 million in tax revenue should be split.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • valdosta high principal.jpg Valdosta High principal to retire

    After one year as Valdosta High School principal, Rufus McDuffie has announced his retirement.

    May 24, 2012 1 Photo

  • Bryan Don by Prop 8x10 HQ.jpg South Georgia’s Ace

    High above war-torn Germany, World War II fighter ace Donald S. “Bush” Bryan led his flight toward an estimated 50 enemy aircraft.

    May 24, 2012 3 Photos

  • Arraignment set for Quitman 11

    The “Quitman Eleven” are scheduled to have an arraignment on May 29, Brooks County Courthouse, according to their attorney, Roy Copeland.

    May 24, 2012

  • Qualifying opens

    Qualifications for Lowndes County general primaries kicked off Wednesday and plenty of folks tossed their proverbial hats in the ring on opening day.

    May 24, 2012

  • 120522 fire3.jpg Fire on Ridgeway Drive

    No injuries were reported after a fire broke out Tuesday morning at an 800 block Ridgeway Drive house.

    May 23, 2012 2 Photos

  • staciawatkins.jpg Lowndes High grad part of ABC’s ‘Duets’


    VALDOSTA — A Lowndes High School graduate is expected to be a part of the debut episode of the new ABC talent-search show “Duets” premiering this week.

    May 23, 2012 1 Photo

Top News
Choose your subscription:
Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
Poll

With schools out, how will your kids spend the day?

Day care / camps
Summer school
With a parent
Spending summer away
Old enough to be alone
     View Results